Why Your Google and Facebook Ads Aren't Generating Profitable Leads
When advertising stops paying for itself, the instinct is to blame the campaigns: new keywords, new audiences, a new agency. Sometimes that's right. More often, the problem sits outside the ad account, in the landing page, the tracking, the CRM or the sales follow-up. This is the diagnostic order Willan Theunissen uses on underperforming accounts, with a calculator to see where your own spend is going.

Clicks, but not customers
Advertising produces three kinds of numbers, and most reports stop at the first:
- Activity metrics: impressions, clicks, click-through rate. They show the ads are running.
- Lead metrics: form fills, calls, cost per lead. They show people are responding.
- Business outcomes: qualified leads, customers, cost per customer and margin. They show whether it’s working.
An account can look healthy on the first two and lose money on the third. The causes below are in the order an online advertising consultant should check them: from the measurement, through the website and the CRM, back to the campaigns.
See where last month’s spend went
Before reading on, put one month of real numbers into the calculator. It splits your spend by where each click left the funnel, which usually makes the biggest leak obvious.
Where did last month's ad spend actually go?
Enter one month from your ad platforms and CRM, then test an improvement at each stage.
Spend is split by where each click left the funnel, at your average cost per click. Improvements are relative: +20% on a 6% rate gives 7.2%. Your numbers stay in your browser.
If most of the spend sits in “clicked but never enquired”, start with the landing page. If it sits in “enquired but not qualified”, look at targeting and the offer. If it sits in “qualified but did not buy”, the problem is probably follow-up or fit, not advertising at all.
Problem 1: You’re optimising for the wrong conversion
Google and Meta optimise towards whatever you tell them is a conversion. If that’s a page view, a button click or every form submission, including duplicates and spam, the platforms will find you more of exactly that.
Check that each conversion action:
- fires once per real enquiry, not on every page load or button click;
- excludes test, spam and duplicate submissions;
- is the most valuable action you can measure reliably, not the easiest.
Bad conversion data doesn’t just distort reports. It teaches the bidding algorithms to buy the wrong people.
Problem 2: Google and Meta are optimising for different signals
Search and social are different kinds of advertising. Google Search reaches people who are already looking: intent is high and volume is limited. Meta reaches people who weren’t looking: volume is large, intent has to be created and lead quality varies more.
Comparing the two on cost per lead alone is misleading. Meta leads are often cheaper and less qualified. Search leads often cost more and close better. Judge each channel on cost per qualified lead and cost per customer, with the same definitions applied to both.
Problem 3: Your landing page is costing you customers
The most common and most expensive leak. Look for:
- A generic destination: every advert leads to the homepage or one general page.
- Message mismatch: the advert promises one thing and the page leads with another.
- Slow or awkward forms, especially on mobile.
- An unclear next step: too many options, or no obvious call to action.
Chery South Africa is a good example. Its campaigns for different models and buyer audiences on Google and Meta all led to the same general page, so every visitor had to look for what they came for. Willan built audience-specific landing pages so each advert’s promise carried through to its page. Measured over three months with the media budget held constant, the cost per lead fell by 32%. Nothing changed in the bidding. The page did the work.
Problem 4: Your leads aren’t contacted or qualified properly
A lead that waits a day for a call is worth less than the same lead called within minutes. Check:
- Time to first contact, by source and by time of day.
- How many attempts are made before a lead is abandoned.
- Routing: does each lead reach the right person automatically?
- CRM statuses: is every lead’s outcome recorded, or do they disappear after the first call?
If outcomes aren’t recorded, nobody can tell which campaigns produce customers, so the advertising can’t improve.
Problem 5: You’re measuring the cheapest leads, not the best customers
Cost per lead is easy to measure and easy to game. The numbers that matter are:
| Metric | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Qualified lead rate | How many leads are actually worth contacting |
| Cost per qualified lead | What a useful lead really costs |
| Sales conversion rate | How many qualified leads become customers |
| Cost per customer | What the advertising costs per sale |
| Contribution margin | Whether each sale makes money after acquisition cost |
A campaign with a higher cost per lead can easily have the lowest cost per customer.
Problem 6: Your campaign structure hides the real winners
When different products, audiences or regions share one campaign, the platform spends where it’s easiest, not where it’s most profitable, and the reports average everything together. Separate what has different economics: products with different margins, audiences with different intent and areas with different close rates. Then give budget to the parts that earn it.
Problem 7: The platforms don’t know what happens after the click
Google and Meta only see the form fill. If a lead turns out to be unqualified, or becomes a large sale, the platforms never find out unless you tell them.
Offline conversion imports send qualified leads and sales from your CRM back to the platforms, so bidding optimises towards customers instead of form fills. They need clean CRM data, a consistent identifier, such as a click ID, and handling that respects consent and POPIA. Done properly, this is often the single largest improvement available to a mature account.
Symptoms and where to look
| Symptom | Possible underlying issue | What to investigate |
|---|---|---|
| High clicks, few leads | Landing page or offer | Engagement, form completion, message match |
| Many leads, few qualified | Targeting or lead quality | Search terms, audiences, qualification outcomes |
| Qualified leads, few sales | Follow-up or offer fit | Contact attempts, response times, close rates |
| Low CPL, high cost per customer | Poor lead-to-sale conversion | CRM outcomes by source and campaign |
| Platform reports disagree | Attribution or event set-up | Event duplication, attribution windows, offline data |
| Results decline as spend grows | Audience saturation or diminishing returns | Marginal cost per customer, frequency, quality |
How a consultant diagnoses the whole funnel
A platform-only audit checks the first link in a four-link chain. Willan’s audits follow the money all the way through:
- Advertising
01 Google and Meta
Structure, search terms, audiences, creative and budget allocation.
- Conversion
02 Landing page
Message match, forms, speed and conversion tracking.
- CRM
03 Lead handling
Routing, response time, qualification and recorded outcomes.
- Outcome
04 Commercial result
Qualified leads, customers, cost per customer and margin.
Verified business outcomes are fed back into the platforms, so campaigns optimise towards customers rather than form fills.
Because Willan is also a software engineer, the fixes don’t stop at recommendations. Landing pages, tracking and CRM integrations can be built, not just flagged.
A 30-day recovery plan
- Days 1–5: Verify the measurement. Audit every conversion action, remove duplicates and agree what a qualified lead is.
- Days 6–10: Reconcile with the CRM. Match a month of platform leads to CRM records and outcomes, by campaign.
- Days 11–15: Fix the biggest leak. Usually the landing page or lead follow-up, based on where the funnel calculator shows the spend going.
- Days 16–25: Restructure where needed. Separate campaigns with different economics, cut search terms and audiences that never qualify.
- Days 26–30: Compare before scaling. Check cost per qualified lead and cost per customer against the starting point before adding any budget.
Don’t increase spend until the measurement is right. Scaling a leaky funnel scales the leak.
Get an independent view
If you’d like Willan to look at your numbers, the first consultation is free.
Questions about underperforming ads
A few useful answers before you decide.
Why are my Google Ads getting clicks but no leads?
Why are my Facebook leads such poor quality?
Should I increase my budget to get more leads?
What is a good cost per lead?
Keep the right things connected.
Online advertising consultant: Willan Theunissen
Work one-to-one with Willan Theunissen: over R90 million in ad spend managed, Google and Meta campaigns that produced measurable results, and the technical depth to fix the landing pages and …

Should You Hire an Online Advertising Consultant, an Agency or an In-House Specialist?
A practical comparison of advertising consultants, agencies and in-house hires: what each costs, who actually does the work, and when each one creates the most commercial value.

How Much Does an Online Advertising Consultant Cost in South Africa?
Fees, retainers and ROI explained: the five pricing models for advertising consultants and agencies, what drives the price, published South African ranges and how to work out whether a …

Measuring Paid Media Beyond Clicks and Impressions
Evaluate paid media with qualified enquiries, sales-stage feedback, delivery checks and honest attribution rather than isolated traffic metrics.
Find out where your ad spend is leaking
Thirty minutes with Willan on your numbers: where the funnel breaks, and what to fix first.
